Top 10 Countertop Ice Makers in 2025: Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

Are you tired of running out of ice during parties or making endless trips to the store for bags of ice? A countertop ice maker could be the ultimate game-changer for your home or office. These compact and efficient appliances produce fresh, crystal-clear ice in just minutes, ensuring you always have a steady supply for drinks, cocktails, and all your cooling needs.

We’ve meticulously tested and reviewed the best countertop ice makers of 2025 to help you find the perfect model tailored to your needs. Our comprehensive buying guide dives deep into crucial factors like ice production rates, types of ice, capacity, and overall value, pinpointing which machines truly deliver on their promises. Whether you’re craving nugget ice, bullet ice, or clear cubes, our top 10 recommendations are here to elevate your ice-making experience.

Top Countertop Ice Makers Compared

Editor’s Choice GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker

Specifications

• Dimensions: 13.43″W x 17.5″D x 16.5″H
• Ice Production: Up to 24 lbs of nugget ice in 24 hours
• Ice Type: Sonic-style nugget ice
• Ice Storage Capacity: 3 lbs
• Side Tank: Optional, triples water capacity
• Smart Features: Wi-Fi connectivity, companion app
• Weight: 38 lbs

The GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker stands as the undisputed champion of countertop ice makers in 2025. It produces the coveted “Sonic-style” nugget ice that’s soft, chewable, and perfect for cocktails, sodas, and everyday beverages. The machine’s sleek design includes a clear ice drawer that lets you monitor ice levels without opening the unit.

What sets the Opal 2.0 apart is the quality of its ice. Unlike solid cubes, these nugget ice pieces are made of compressed ice flakes, giving them that satisfying chewable texture that ice enthusiasts crave. The machine can produce up to 24 pounds of ice per day, ensuring you’ll never run short during gatherings.

The optional side tank triples the water capacity, reducing the frequency of refills. While the price point is higher than basic bullet ice makers, the premium ice quality and robust construction make it worth the investment for serious ice enthusiasts.

Gevi Household V2.0 Countertop Nugget Ice Maker

Specifications

• Dimensions: 17.2″D x 9.6″W x 16.7″H
• Ice Production: Up to 30 lbs of ice in 24 hours
• Ice Type: Nugget ice
• Ice Storage Capacity: 2.8 lbs
• Water Connection: Optional direct water line connection
• Weight: 34 lbs

The Gevi Household V2.0 Countertop Nugget Ice Maker is a strong contender in the premium ice maker category. While its nugget ice isn’t quite as perfectly textured as the Opal’s, it comes very close while offering some advantages of its own.

This machine excels in ice production capacity, generating up to 30 pounds of nugget ice per day—25% more than the Opal. The option to connect directly to a water line (adapter sold separately) eliminates the need for manual refilling, making it ideal for high-usage environments.

The Gevi operates more quietly than many competitors and features a simpler cleaning cycle. Its sleek design looks high-end, though the solid door means you can’t check ice levels without opening the unit. For those who want quality nugget ice at a slightly lower price point than the Opal, the Gevi V2.0 is an excellent choice.

Igloo Premium Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker

Specifications

• Dimensions: 9″ x 12″ x 12″
• Ice Production: 26 lbs/day
• Ice Type: Bullet
• Ice Size Options: 2
• Ice Storage Capacity: 2 lbs
• Self-Cleaning: Yes
• Weight: 17 lbs

The Igloo Premium Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker offers exceptional value for those who want reliable ice production without the premium price tag of nugget ice makers. This compact unit is remarkably efficient for its size, producing nearly a pound of bullet ice per hour and delivering its first batch in under 8 minutes.

What sets this model apart from other budget-friendly options is its convenient handle—similar to that of a cooler—which combined with its lightweight build makes it truly portable. The self-cleaning function works effectively, making maintenance simple and straightforward.

The clear control panel with intuitive indicator lights allows you to check the machine’s status at a glance. While bullet ice doesn’t have the premium chewable quality of nugget ice, it’s perfectly suitable for most everyday uses and cools drinks efficiently. For the price, this is an outstanding option that balances performance, portability, and value.

NewAir Countertop Ice Maker

Specifications

• Dimensions: 13.5″ x 16″ x 16″
• Ice Production: 44 lbs/day
• Ice Type: Bullet
• Ice Size Options: 3
• Ice Storage Capacity: 2.5 lbs
• Self-Cleaning: Yes
• Weight: 30 lbs

The NewAir Countertop Ice Maker is the speed champion among our top 10 picks, producing an impressive 44 pounds of ice per day—nearly 2 pounds per hour once it’s up and running. If you frequently entertain or need large quantities of ice quickly, this model delivers exceptional performance.

Despite its larger size and weight, the NewAir includes convenient handles that make it surprisingly portable and easy to move when needed. The simple controls allow you to toggle between three different ice sizes or activate the effective self-cleaning function with minimal fuss.

The water recirculation system works optimally to collect and refreeze runoff, ensuring efficient operation and minimal waste. While the drain plug design could be improved (it’s awkwardly positioned on the side), this is a minor inconvenience in an otherwise excellent machine. For those who prioritize production capacity over the premium texture of nugget ice, the NewAir is an outstanding choice.

Luma Comfort Clear Ice Maker

Specifications

• Dimensions: 11″ x 14″ x 13.5″
• Ice Production: 28 lbs/day
• Ice Type: Clear cubes
• Ice Size Options: 2
• Ice Storage Capacity: 2.2 lbs
• Self-Cleaning: No
• Weight: 24 lbs

The Luma Comfort Clear Ice Maker is the top choice for those who prioritize ice quality and presentation over production speed. This machine produces crystal-clear ice cubes that are not only visually appealing but also functionally superior for certain uses—particularly for carbonated beverages and premium cocktails.

Clear ice keeps carbonated drinks fizzy significantly longer than cloudy ice, as it contains fewer air bubbles that cause fizzing. It also melts more slowly, making it ideal for sipping drinks that you don’t want diluted quickly. The machine allows you to adjust ice thickness, which is useful in warmer environments to ensure proper ice formation.

The trade-off is slower production—about 20-25 minutes per batch compared to 7-9 minutes for bullet ice makers. You’ll also need to manually break apart the ice sheets, and the machine lacks a self-cleaning function. However, for cocktail enthusiasts, entertainers who value presentation, or anyone who enjoys carbonated beverages, the superior quality of clear ice makes these compromises worthwhile.

Magic Chef MCIM22 Ice Maker

Specifications

• Dimensions: 9.5″ x 12.9″ x 14″
• Ice Production: 27 lbs/day
• Ice Type: Bullet
• Ice Size Options: 2
• Ice Storage Capacity: 1.5 lbs
• Self-Cleaning: No
• Weight: 17.8 lbs

The Magic Chef MCIM22 Ice Maker offers reliable performance at a reasonable price point, making it a popular choice for everyday home use. This straightforward machine produces nine bullet-shaped ice cubes approximately every 8 minutes, with a daily capacity of 27 pounds.

One standout feature is its larger water reservoir, which allows for continuous ice production for several hours without refilling—a convenience that shouldn’t be underestimated. The controls are intuitive and simple to use, with clear indicators for ice size selection and machine status.

While the stainless steel finish looks sleek, it does show fingerprints more prominently than some other models. The lack of a self-cleaning function means more manual maintenance is required. However, the machine’s reliability, combined with wide availability through major retailers (making returns hassle-free if needed), makes this a solid choice for those seeking a dependable ice maker without premium features or price.

Frigidaire Compact Ice Maker

Specifications

• Dimensions: 9″ x 13″ x 12″
• Ice Production: 26 lbs/day
• Ice Type: Bullet
• Ice Size Options: 2
• Ice Storage Capacity: 1.8 lbs
• Self-Cleaning: No
• Weight: 18 lbs

The Frigidaire Compact Ice Maker offers solid performance in a space-saving design, making it ideal for smaller kitchens, RVs, or offices. This machine produces relatively large bullet ice at a good pace, generating about 1 pound per hour—sufficient for most household needs.

One convenient feature is the transparent top, which allows you to check ice levels without opening the machine. The controls are simple and intuitive, making operation straightforward even for first-time users. As a product from a well-established brand, it also offers the reassurance of reliable customer support if needed.

The main drawbacks are the lack of a self-cleaning function and a drain plug that’s particularly difficult to remove. Manual cleaning can be tedious, as reaching all internal components is challenging. However, if you’re looking for a compact, reliable ice maker from a trusted brand and don’t mind the extra maintenance, the Frigidaire offers good value for its price point.

Euhomy Portable Nugget Ice Maker

Specifications

• Dimensions: 9.45″D x 11.61″W x 12.99″H
• Ice Production: 24 lbs/day
• Ice Type: Nugget
• Ice Size Options: 1
• Ice Storage Capacity: 1.5 lbs
• Self-Cleaning: Yes
• Weight: 15 lbs

The Euhomy Portable Nugget Ice Maker represents a significant breakthrough in the market—an affordable, compact machine that produces nugget-style ice. While premium nugget ice makers like the Opal 2.0 have dominated this category with high price points, the Euhomy offers a budget-friendly alternative for those who crave chewable ice.

This truly portable unit features a carry handle and weighs just 15 pounds, making it ideal for small spaces, RVs, boats, or taking to parties. The nugget ice it produces is different from premium models—it comes out firmer and almost clear, becoming softer and more chewable after sitting in the ice basket for a while.

The machine operates more quietly than larger models and is simple to use. While the ice quality and production capacity don’t match the premium nugget ice makers, the significantly lower price point makes this an attractive option for those who want chewable ice without the premium investment. It’s a good entry point into nugget ice making before committing to a more expensive model.

Silonn Countertop Ice Maker

Specifications

• Dimensions: 8.5″ x 11.5″ x 12″
• Ice Production: 26 lbs/day
• Ice Type: Bullet
• Ice Size Options: 2
• Ice Storage Capacity: 1.8 lbs
• Self-Cleaning: Yes
• Weight: 15 lbs

The Silonn Countertop Ice Maker is one of the most compact and affordable options on our list, making it ideal for very small spaces or occasional use. Weighing just 15 pounds and with a footprint of only 8.5″ x 11.5″, it can fit in tight spaces where larger models wouldn’t be practical.

This budget-friendly machine includes a self-cleaning function—a feature not always found at this price point. The control panel is straightforward and easy to use, and the operation is relatively quiet compared to some larger models.

The trade-offs for the compact size and low price are slower ice production and smaller ice cubes that tend to melt more quickly than those from other machines. The self-cleaning cycle, while useful, takes a full 30 minutes and doesn’t provide any indication when it’s complete. For those with limited space or budget who need ice occasionally rather than constantly, the Silonn offers good value despite these limitations.

Whynter Nugget Ice Maker

Specifications

• Dimensions: 9.5″ x 14″ x 13″
• Ice Production: 33 lbs/day
• Ice Type: Nugget
• Ice Size Options: 1
• Ice Storage Capacity: 2.5 lbs
• Self-Cleaning: Yes
• Weight: 34 lbs

The Whynter Nugget Ice Maker stands out for its compact height—it’s considerably shorter than other nugget ice makers, making it one of the few that can fit under standard upper kitchen cabinets. This is a significant advantage for those with limited vertical space who still want the premium experience of nugget ice.

The machine produces good quality nugget ice at a respectable rate, with a daily capacity of 33 pounds. The self-cleaning function works effectively, simplifying maintenance. However, the initial setup can be more complicated than with other models, requiring careful attention to the manual.

While the ice quality is good, the ice drawer is relatively small, meaning you’ll need to empty it more frequently during heavy use. The machine also operates more loudly than some competitors. For those who prioritize a shorter height profile while still wanting nugget ice, the Whynter offers a good solution despite its premium price point and few drawbacks.

How We Selected and Tested These Ice Makers

Our comprehensive evaluation process involved both laboratory testing and real-world usage to determine which countertop ice makers truly deliver on their promises. We focused on several key factors:

Selection Criteria

• Ice Type Variety: We selected machines producing three distinct ice types—bullet ice, nugget ice, and clear ice—to cover all preferences.
• Price Range: We included models across various price points, from budget-friendly options under $150 to premium machines over $500.
• Brand Reputation: We prioritized established brands with proven track records for reliability and customer service.
• User Reviews: We analyzed thousands of verified customer reviews to identify consistent strengths and weaknesses.

Testing Process

• Ice Production Speed: We measured how quickly each machine produced its first batch of ice and its hourly production rate.
• Ice Quality: We evaluated ice clarity, texture, chewability, and melting rate in various beverages.
• Ease of Use: We assessed setup complexity, control intuitiveness, and maintenance requirements.
• Noise Levels: We measured decibel levels during operation to determine which machines were quietest.
• Long-Term Testing: We used each machine continuously for several weeks to evaluate durability and consistency.

Our testing revealed significant differences in performance, particularly between ice types. Nugget ice makers generally commanded higher prices but delivered a premium ice experience. Bullet ice makers offered the best value for everyday use, while clear ice makers excelled for cocktails and carbonated beverages.

Final Recommendation: Which Countertop Ice Maker Should You Buy?

Your ideal ice maker depends primarily on your priorities:

Best for Most People

If you want reliable ice production at a reasonable price, the Igloo Premium Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker offers the best balance of performance, portability, and value. Its self-cleaning function and convenient handle make it exceptionally user-friendly.

Best for Ice Quality

Ice enthusiasts who prioritize texture and chewability should invest in the GE Profile Opal 2.0. Its perfect nugget ice is unmatched for cocktails, soft drinks, and everyday enjoyment.

Best for High Volume

If you frequently entertain or need large quantities of ice quickly, the NewAir Countertop Ice Maker delivers with its impressive 44 pounds per day capacity and rapid production rate.

Best for Cocktails

Cocktail enthusiasts should consider the Luma Comfort Clear Ice Maker, which produces crystal-clear ice that melts slowly and won’t dilute premium spirits too quickly.

Best Budget Option

For those on a tight budget, the Silonn Countertop Ice Maker provides reliable performance in an ultra-compact package at an affordable price point.

Whichever model you choose, a countertop ice maker eliminates the hassle of ice trays and store-bought bags while ensuring you always have fresh ice for your favorite beverages. The convenience these machines offer makes them a worthwhile addition to any kitchen, home bar, or entertainment space.